Skip to content
Small Business UK

Small Business UK

Advice and Ideas for UK Small Businesses and SMEs

  • Subscribe
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • RSS
  • Starting
    • Start a New Business
      • Setting up your business
      • Getting your business going
    • Advice
    • Funding
    • Ideas & planning
    • Investing in a franchise
    • Setting up a company
    • Sole trader
    • Success stories
    • Work life balance
  • Financing
    • Accounts & Tax
    • Alternative finance
      • Crowdfunding for Business
    • Banking
    • Business Loans
    • Grants
    • Payroll
  • Running
    • Business management
    • Buying and selling a company
    • Employing & managing staff
    • Export & Import
    • Finding and selling to customers
    • Insurance
    • Masterclass Series
    • International Business
    • Legal advice
    • Marketing
    • Office & home working
    • Getting Online
    • Technology
    • Taking Payments
    • Productivity
    • Smart Energy GB
  • News
    • Law
    • Management
    • Opportunities
    • Outlook
    • Partner Content
  • Podcast
  • Guides
    • Guides
    • Series
  • Business Tools
    • Start-Up Series
      • About
      • How to enter
      • Partners
    • Funding Your Small Business
    • Making Tax Digital
    • Website Checker
  • Starting
    • Start a New Business
      • Setting up your business
      • Getting your business going
    • Advice
    • Funding
    • Ideas & planning
    • Investing in a franchise
    • Setting up a company
    • Sole trader
    • Success stories
    • Work life balance
  • Financing
    • Accounts & Tax
    • Alternative finance
      • Crowdfunding for Business
    • Banking
    • Business Loans
    • Grants
    • Payroll
  • Running
    • Business management
    • Buying and selling a company
    • Employing & managing staff
    • Export & Import
    • Finding and selling to customers
    • Insurance
    • Masterclass Series
    • International Business
    • Legal advice
    • Marketing
    • Office & home working
    • Getting Online
    • Technology
    • Taking Payments
    • Productivity
    • Smart Energy GB
  • News
    • Law
    • Management
    • Opportunities
    • Outlook
    • Partner Content
  • Podcast
  • Guides
    • Guides
    • Series
  • Business Tools
    • Start-Up Series
      • About
      • How to enter
      • Partners
    • Funding Your Small Business
    • Making Tax Digital
    • Website Checker
  • Subscribe
Home » Running a Business » Legal advice » How to avoid unfair dismissal claims

How to avoid unfair dismissal claims

Hard evidence: make sure that you don't get accused of unfair dismissal

by Simon Robinson26 July 2021

Simon Robinson, managing partner of RobinsonRalph, gives an overview of the basics to help you avoid paying any unnecessary compensation and explains the basis for claims of unfair dismissal.

Dismissing an employee is never an easy process, and many employers will avoid taking action against a problem or under-performing member of staff out of fear of a claim in the employment tribunal.

However, while the dismissal process may seem complicated and risky, for many businesses, failing to tackle problem employees can have huge repercussions for the future; and a failure to act risks damaging the business in both the short and longer term.

Wrongful and unfair dismissal

Wrongful dismissal is a dismissal in breach of the employee’s contract and applies where the employer has terminated employment without full notice. The value of a wrongful dismissal claim is usually limited to the pay and benefits the employee would have received during the notice period provided by the employment contract.

Unfair dismissal is where employment is terminated, and the employer did not have a fair reason for the dismissal. Alternatively, a dismissal may have been fair in theory, but the employer’s failure to follow the correct procedure renders it unfair as a result.

Termination of contract. Is it unfair dismissal?

It is worthwhile noting that an individual will require two years of service before they are eligible to bring a claim in the employment tribunal for unfair dismissal. This period of service, know as the ‘qualifying period’ does not apply however to discrimination claims.

Employers will therefore need to be very clear about the reasons behind any dismissal process. They must ensure they are not directly or indirectly discriminating against the employee in question, or that the reasons behind any under-performance or misconduct relate to any of the protected characteristics within The Equality Act 2010, such as disability causing sickness absence.

There is no qualifying period for a wrongful dismissal claim.

What is fair?

A fair dismissal is one that is based upon one of five potentially fair reasons. These are: the individual’s conduct, their capability or qualifications for the job, redundancy, a statutory duty or restriction prohibiting the employment being continued or because of a substantial reason which justifies the dismissal.

See also: The Small Business guide to HR

In addition to the requirement of a potentially fair reason as a baseline, employers must also ensure that the dismissal process they follow is procedurally fair. This means that they must follow their disciplinary policy and the ACAS Code of Practice (which in practice is likely to be similar to the policy). Failure to follow the ACAS code can result in a 25 per cent uplift to any damages awarded to an unfairly dismissed individual.

“Employers must also ensure that the dismissal process they follow is procedurally fair”

Further, an employee should know the allegations against them, as well as that dismissal is a possible outcome; they should be allowed to make representations, be accompanied at the disciplinary and appeal hearings and be given a right of appeal.

The following are all examples of potentially fair reasons for dismissing an employee:

Conduct – Where the employee’s behaviour is seriously unacceptable, for example, repeated lateness or drunkenness at work.

Capability – Where the employee doesn’t have the right skills or aptitude to do the job or is frequently absent through ill-health.

You should always consider training to improve capabilities or moving an employee to a suitable alternative position, with their consent, before dismissal. Remember that is it unlawful for an employer to discriminate against a person because of a disability. You have a duty to make ‘reasonable adjustments’ to workplaces and working practices to make sure that employees with a disability are not at a substantial disadvantage compared to other people.

Legality – To avoid breaking the law, for example, where the loss of their driving licence means the taxi driver cannot drive legally.

Redundancy – For example, where there is insufficient work or an employer is closing down entirely.

Some other substantial reason – This is called the catch-all reason but it should be used carefully, as you have to show that the reason was ‘substantial’. A major company restructuring could be an example.

Remember of course that all of the above examples are not ‘fair’ reasons until the procedure has been followed and the allegations investigated and proven. Failure to follow the procedure, as noted above, is likely to render a potentially fair dismissal, procedurally unfair.

Compensation for unfair dismissal

The maximum award for compensation for unfair dismissal is £89,493, or 52 weeks’ gross salary – whichever is the lower of the two. These limits apply for a dismissal on or after April 6 2021.

How to stay within the law

Employers must have detailed and up-to-date employment contracts in place, and need to show that they have followed the correct procedures laid out in these contracts fairly and competently.

In situations in which a dismissal is a potential outcome, they must be scrupulously careful in ensuring they follow all procedural steps. They may also want to consider taking external advice from either an employment solicitor or HR practitioner to guide them through the process, and act as a third party observer.

Employers who dismiss unilaterally, or without reference to the five potentially fair reasons outlined earlier put themselves at significant risk of tribunal claims. In any event, it is always sensible to take detailed legal advice on all matters that could result in the dismissal of an employee.

You are advised to take legal advice in respect of the particular case before dismissing any employee.

Simon Robinson is managing partner of RobinsonRalph.

Tagged: Managing Staff

Related Topics

Managing Staff

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related Stories

Legal advice

What is the UKCA mark and how does it affect my small business?

We explain the new UKCA mark which has replaced the CE mark for products sold on the market in Great Britain

Legal advice

Plastic Packaging Tax – what does it mean for my small business?

From April 2022, businesses will be liable to pay Plastic Packaging Tax. We explore what it is and whether it will affect you

Legal advice

How to obtain a UK patent – a 10-point checklist

Obtaining a patent can be time-consuming and expensive. But a patent can prevent others from using your invention, generate licensing income, encourage investment and even lower your tax bill

Legal advice

Can my employer stop me from setting up a competing business?

What you can and can’t do when setting up in competition against your former employment is often in the fine print of your contract, warns Harper James Solicitors

Helping you grow your business is our number one priority, if you would like to take your business to the next step just sign up!

sign up now

Related Stories

Legal advice

What is the UKCA mark and how does it affect my small business?

We explain the new UKCA mark which has replaced the CE mark for products sold on the market in Great Britain

Legal advice

Plastic Packaging Tax – what does it mean for my small business?

From April 2022, businesses will be liable to pay Plastic Packaging Tax. We explore what it is and whether it will affect you

Legal advice

How to obtain a UK patent – a 10-point checklist

Obtaining a patent can be time-consuming and expensive. But a patent can prevent others from using your invention, generate licensing income, encourage investment and even lower your tax bill

Legal advice

GDPR three years on: make sure your small business is compliant

Many small businesses think if they just ignore the EU’s GDPR regulations, they will just go away. Lawyer Chris Cook warns SMEs they face crippling fines if they do nothing

SmallBusiness.co.uk provides advice and useful guides to UK sole traders and small businesses. Our goal is to help owner managers and entrepreneurs to start, run, grow and succeed in business, helping turn your business idea into a profitable business.

The Bonhill Network

  • Bonhill Group plc
  • Information Age
  • InvestmentNews
  • What Investment
  • Growth Business
  • Tax Guide
  • DiversityQ

Further Information

  • Contact Details
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Blog
  • About this Website
  • Media Packs
  • Contributor guidelines
  • Small Business Whitepapers

Contact us

  • 0207 7638 6378

Address

  • Bonhill Group plc
  • 29 Clerkenwell Road
  • London
  • EC1M 5RN

A part of the Bonhill Group