Institute of Fiscal Studies tax report fundamentally flawed says FCSA

The difference in National Insurance Contribution rates between employed and self-employed is not unfair, argues the FCSA.

A report just out suggesting that the different tax rates of National Insurance Contributions (NICs) between self-employed workers and employees are unfair is fundamentally flawed, argues the Freelancer & Contractor Services Association (FCSA).

The Institute of Fiscal Studies (IFS) believes that the differential NICs rates should be aligned because, in their opinion, there is minimal difference in state benefits funded by NICs for self-employed and employed people.

However, FCSA argues that this is a fundamentally flawed position to take – self-employed people do not have access to NICs funded statutory benefits like unemployment benefit or sick pay and when it comes to maternity allowance, employees receive at least 57 per cent more in maternity pay than self-employed workers, based on FCSA’s analysis of a 2012 survey by XPertHR.

The IFS report also claims that the self-employed have the same entitlement to the new state pension. However, setting the record straight, FCSA points out that self-employed workers are not part of the new auto-enrolment model, so they cannot access the tax relief that is afforded to employees and funded by NICs under the new scheme.

Furthermore, they will need to have paid 35+ years of NICs in order to receive the state pension, and many self-employed people might not be in this position so it is far from a level playing field.

Julia Kermode, FCSA’s chief executive says, ‘Once again the self-employed are coming under attack for not paying enough tax with IFS arguing that the NICs system needs addressing so that employees are not being penalised by an unfair system. That is wholly unjustifiable and they should take a proper look at their figures and the differential benefits provided that account for the different NICs rates paid.

‘Freelancers and contractors are the backbone of our economy and have been propping up UK plc since the recession and they should be celebrated and supported not chastised and penalised. It is worth pointing out that the self-employed do not want or expect these state benefits but if the NICs rates are to be aligned then at the very least the access to benefits needs to be matched. And that could cost the UK government dearly.’

Further reading on tax reports

Owen Gough, SmallBusiness UK

Owen Gough

Owen was a reporter for Bonhill Group plc writing across the and titles before moving on to be a Digital Technology reporter for the

Related Topics

Leave a comment