Skip to content
Small Business UK

Small Business UK

Advice and Ideas for UK Small Businesses and SMEs

  • Subscribe
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • RSS
  • Starting
    • Start a New Business
      • Setting up your business
      • Getting your business going
    • Advice
    • Funding
    • Ideas & planning
    • Investing in a franchise
    • Setting up a company
    • Sole trader
    • Success stories
    • Work life balance
  • Financing
    • Accounts & Tax
    • Alternative finance
      • Crowdfunding for Business
    • Banking
    • Business Loans
    • Grants
    • Payroll
  • Running
    • Business management
    • Buying and selling a company
    • Employing & managing staff
    • Export & Import
    • Finding and selling to customers
    • Insurance
    • Masterclass Series
    • International Business
    • Legal advice
    • Marketing
    • Office & home working
    • Getting Online
    • Technology
    • Taking Payments
    • Productivity
    • Smart Energy GB
  • News
    • Law
    • Management
    • Opportunities
    • Outlook
    • Partner Content
  • Podcast
  • Guides
    • Guides
    • Series
  • Business Tools
    • Start-Up Series
      • About
      • How to enter
      • Partners
    • Funding Your Small Business
    • Making Tax Digital
    • Website Checker
  • Starting
    • Start a New Business
      • Setting up your business
      • Getting your business going
    • Advice
    • Funding
    • Ideas & planning
    • Investing in a franchise
    • Setting up a company
    • Sole trader
    • Success stories
    • Work life balance
  • Financing
    • Accounts & Tax
    • Alternative finance
      • Crowdfunding for Business
    • Banking
    • Business Loans
    • Grants
    • Payroll
  • Running
    • Business management
    • Buying and selling a company
    • Employing & managing staff
    • Export & Import
    • Finding and selling to customers
    • Insurance
    • Masterclass Series
    • International Business
    • Legal advice
    • Marketing
    • Office & home working
    • Getting Online
    • Technology
    • Taking Payments
    • Productivity
    • Smart Energy GB
  • News
    • Law
    • Management
    • Opportunities
    • Outlook
    • Partner Content
  • Podcast
  • Guides
    • Guides
    • Series
  • Business Tools
    • Start-Up Series
      • About
      • How to enter
      • Partners
    • Funding Your Small Business
    • Making Tax Digital
    • Website Checker
  • Subscribe
Home » Running a Business » Legal advice » When poor performance becomes a legal issue: what do you do?

When poor performance becomes a legal issue: what do you do?

How poor performance can quickly become a legal issue for businesses

Owen Gough, SmallBusiness UKby Owen Gough14 June 2017

Here, Asif Robbani, LLB(Hons) LLM, director of Francis George Solicitor Advocate, discusses the legal issues of poor performance at work.

Pursuant to section 98 (2) (a) of the Employment Rights Act 1996, capability (by way of poor performance) is potentially a fair reason for dismissal.

Poor performance is an allegation in which the employer finds that an employee’s work is not to a particular standard. For instance, an employee may be missing sales or other business targets, deadlines and/or making mistakes in their work.

If there are issues relating to poor performance, an employer will be at real risk of a claim for unfair dismissal if they fail to follow a fair process.

Before commencing a formal disciplinary procedure, it would be sensible for the employer to address performance issues informally if at all possible. This could include a performance improvement plan.

It is usual for an organisation to have its own policies when dealing with matters relating to poor performance. ACAS also have a code of practice which many organisations either base their internal policies upon and/or use in conjunction with their existing policy.

If an organisation does not have its own policy, an Employment Tribunal would, at the very least, expect to see compliance with the ACAS’ code of practice failing which any Order for damages (assuming that an employee is successful in a claim for unfair dismissal) could be increased. The ACAS code of practice provides guidance for employers to ensure that performance issues are dealt with fairly at work.

There are a series of steps that are recommended within the ACAS code of Practice which an employer should be mindful of (as well as their own internal policy) when dealing with performance issues. They are as follows:-

A thorough investigation

An employer should carry out adequate investigations to ascertain the facts to see whether an allegation of poor performance has merit. During this process, the employer should identify all of the key evidence to support the allegation.

An investigation may include monitoring, reviewing appraisals and/or reviewing stats with other seniors. A thorough process should also identify the reasons for the poor performance. This is crucial because it may be the case that the poor performance has arisen as a consequence of the employer’s failings – and not the employees. For instance, poor performance could arise due to inadequate training given to the employee. If that was the case, a subsequent termination of employment (due to poor performance) could be met by an immediate claim for unfair dismissal by an aggrieved employee.

A fair and thorough investigation could therefore prevent claims at the Employment Tribunal.

For the avoidance of doubt, employers and employees should be mindful of the fact that an investigatory meeting should be impartial. It should not amount to and/or be regarded as a disciplinary action itself.

Keep employees fully aware

There is an obligation to keep the employee updated throughout all stages.

Following an investigation, if there is a case to answer then an employer should notify the employee the following in writing:-

  • the nature of the poor performance
  • the possible consequences
  • appropriate evidence
  • time and venue of the disciplinary meeting
  • the right to be accompanied at the meeting by a work colleague, a trade union representative or an official employed by a trade union

Employers are reminded that a failure to follow the above could be regarded as a breach of the ACAS Code of Practice and could result in an uplift in damages if the employee successfully pursues a claim for Unfair Dismissal.

Employers are also reminded that an invitation to a disciplinary meeting and the disciplinary meeting itself should not be regarded as disciplinary action. Rather, they are a means of investigating whether there is a case for poor performance.

Warnings and opportunities to improve

Following a disciplinary meeting, the employer will determine whether disciplinary action is justified.

If having reviewed the evidence and the employee’s version of events (during the investigation meeting), a finding of poor performance is made, an employer can issue the employee with a first written warning.

The warning should identify the nature of the poor performance together with the level of improvement required. Reasonable timescales should also be included in addition to dates for periodic reviews. A reasonable timescale depends upon the facts of each case. Factors to consider may be the level of poor performance, the employee’s length of service and/or the impact of the poor performance upon the business.

An employer should also inform the employee about the consequences of further disciplinary action. That can include a final written warning or even a dismissal (if the employee is at the final written stage).

Dependent upon the nature of the poor performance and/or the impact of it, poor performance may justify an immediate final warning. Before making that decision, an employer should consult with Solicitors.

Right to appeal

This is a procedural element which some employers may fail to comply with.

If an employee is unhappy with the employer’s decision, they have the right to appeal. An employer must therefore ensure that (a) they inform the employee of that right and (b) they have an appeal process in place.

Notice of the employee’s right to appeal should be given at the time that the disciplinary action is taken. A time scale for filing an appeal should also be given (usually 5 working days).

An appeal should be dealt with impartially and ideally by a different manager (if at all possible). As with the initial disciplinary meeting, the employee has a statutory right to be accompanied at an appeal hearing, and which should be heard without delay.

Dismissal for performance

In some cases, a dismissal for poor performance may be inevitable.

An employer should firstly consider whether there are any conduct issues that can be relied on. That may be a safer and quicker method for dismissing an employee. For instance, persistent lateness and/or rudeness by an employee and/or bring the organisation into disrepute.

If a finding of poor performance is made, it is usual for employer’s to set targets and improvement levels. Targets need to be measurable and achievable with guidance and support provided.

The review of the employee’s performance need not be too long. It simply needs to be reasonable for the employee to achieve the objective. Review periods typically last between 4 to 12 weeks depending upon the circumstances.

At the end of each performance review period, meetings should be held to review the employee’s performance. If the performance has not improved, then a warning should be issued and a further performance review period should be entered into. If at the end of the second performance review period there is no improvement, the employer could issue a final written warning.

If there is still no improvement, an employer should consider dismissal at a final performance review meeting. It would be sensible for the employer to seek legal advice at all stages to minimise the risk of a claim for unfair dismissal.

If there is a dismissal, it should be on notice. An employer should be mindful of the fact that poor performance does not amount to gross misconduct.

Evidence of the employee’s poor performance should be kept and reviewed with the employee at each stage of the process. All evidence should be preserved given that it will be used to defend a case for unfair dismissal if the employee decides to proceed with a claim.

Legal alternatives

An employer should be mindful of the fact that an employee could also lodge a grievance if the employee does not agree with the performance process and/or the outcome. Although the employee should try to resolve all grievances informally in the first instance (depending upon the seriousness of the grievance) a formal process may be inevitable.

To avoid animosity, the parties could try and reach an agreement on mutual terms by entering into a Settlement Agreement. That will often involve the termination of the employee’s employment. This is a highly tactical position and should not be adopted by either party without first seeking legal advice.

Asif Robbani, LLB(Hons) LLM is director of Francis George Solicitor Advocate.

Further reading on legal issues in business

  • The legal challenges facing UK small business

Tagged: Employment Law

Related Topics

Employment Law

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related Stories

Legal advice

What are the new rules on calculating holiday pay for seasonal workers?

The Harpur Trust v Brazel case has challenged the way that seasonal and part-year worker holiday pay is calculated. What should you do now?

Legal advice

What is the UKCA mark and how does it affect my small business?

We explain the new UKCA mark which has replaced the CE mark for products sold on the market in Great Britain

Legal advice

Plastic Packaging Tax – what does it mean for my small business?

From April 2022, businesses will be liable to pay Plastic Packaging Tax. We explore what it is and whether it will affect you

Legal advice

How to obtain a UK patent – a 10-point checklist

Obtaining a patent can be time-consuming and expensive. But a patent can prevent others from using your invention, generate licensing income, encourage investment and even lower your tax bill

Helping you grow your business is our number one priority, if you would like to take your business to the next step just sign up!

sign up now

Related Stories

Legal advice

What are the new rules on calculating holiday pay for seasonal workers?

The Harpur Trust v Brazel case has challenged the way that seasonal and part-year worker holiday pay is calculated. What should you do now?

Legal advice

What is the UKCA mark and how does it affect my small business?

We explain the new UKCA mark which has replaced the CE mark for products sold on the market in Great Britain

Legal advice

Plastic Packaging Tax – what does it mean for my small business?

From April 2022, businesses will be liable to pay Plastic Packaging Tax. We explore what it is and whether it will affect you

Legal advice

Can my employer stop me from setting up a competing business?

What you can and can’t do when setting up in competition against your former employment is often in the fine print of your contract, warns Harper James Solicitors

SmallBusiness.co.uk provides advice and useful guides to UK sole traders and small businesses. Our goal is to help owner managers and entrepreneurs to start, run, grow and succeed in business, helping turn your business idea into a profitable business.

The Bonhill Network

  • Bonhill Group plc
  • Information Age
  • InvestmentNews
  • What Investment
  • Growth Business
  • Tax Guide
  • DiversityQ

Further Information

  • Contact Details
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Blog
  • About this Website
  • Media Packs
  • Contributor guidelines
  • Small Business Whitepapers

Contact us

  • 0207 7638 6378

Address

  • Bonhill Group plc
  • 29 Clerkenwell Road
  • London
  • EC1M 5RN

A part of the Bonhill Group